Unbelievable Chicken
The beautiful weather has arrived in New England! So, I was itchin to grill this weekend. I love to grill up big batches of chicken and then refrigerate the leftovers for easy lunches and weeknight dinners. Chicken is a great choice for the grill. It gets a 39 on the NuVal scale. Compare that to 85% lean hamburgers, which get a score of 28, and you’ll pick the chicken, right?
I have a couple of Go To recipes that I typically use, like Martha Stewart’s Grilled Chicken Paillard, but I was feeling adventurous this weekend. I decided to google a new chicken recipe. I know, I know, I live on the wild side!
When you search Allrecipes.com for grilled chicken, the top recipe that pops up is called Unbelievable Chicken. The submitter of the recipe says, “This unusual combination of common ingredients is fabulous! Everyone who tastes it asks me to share the recipe. You will love it and the many compliments you get – I promise.” Hmmmm. That seemed convincing. So, I went to work.
First, I got out my ingredients:
Cider Vinegar
Coarse-Ground Mustard
Garlic
Lime
Lemon (I did not have one, so I used lemon juice)
Brown Sugar
Salt
Black Pepper
Olive Oil
For exact measurements, you can check out the recipe here. I marinated it overnight.
I hate lighting the grill. We bought a new grill a couple of years ago and I thought it would light easily. But it does not. So you have to throw a match into it. I really hate lighting the grill. So, I leave that up to my husband. That means he also ends up cooking on the grill.
He does a great job!
He even took this photo for me because I was off teaching Pilates when he finished grilling the chicken. What a guy!
So was this chicken unbelievable? Well, it was very, very good for dinner. It actually was better the next day when I had is sliced cold on a salad. I love recipes that taste even better the next day. So, I would definitely recommend that you try it out.
Question of the Day
Tell me your favorite recipe for marinating chicken. I’m always up for something new!
Winner of Yesterday’s GiveAway
Congratulations to Commenter #10, Ibu! You’ve won the Planter’s NUT-rition GiveAway. Send me an email at abetterbagofgroceries@gmail.com with your mailing address. Thanks to all who entered.
Posted by: Melissa 5 comments
Posted in: Uncategorized
Tags: Chicken, Unbelievable Chicken





on May 5th, 2010 at 8:12 am
This is really simple, but marinate it in your favorite mustard and then grill it, broil it, or bake it. Delicious!
on May 5th, 2010 at 10:51 am
My all time favorite is from Barefoot Contessa and perfect for tonight’s Cinco de Mayo dinner – Tequila Lime Chicken. SO yummy and definitely better the next day.
on May 5th, 2010 at 1:22 pm
that chicken looks so good! happy cinco de mayo melissa!
on May 5th, 2010 at 4:03 pm
Grill Master husband! Chicken looks very good. I usually do a dry rub on my chix but ocassionally I do fresh diced garlic, terriyaki sauce and olive oil marinade.
on May 5th, 2010 at 4:07 pm
I just throw some chicken breasts in the crockpot, cover with a couple cans of cream of something soup — whatever is on hand: celery, mushroom, chicken etc — healthy request versions, and cook on low for about 8 hours. Then I serve with brown or parboiled white rice (which scores same as brown!). So easy and so good.